Eighteen months ago there was one screenless fitness band worth naming, and you could not buy it. You rented it, for $199 a year or more [1].
Today there are six. Two cost $99.99, and one will be given away [2][3][4].
All six are sold on the same promise: a recovery score built from heart rate variability, or HRV. Here is the part the reviews skip. On most of these bands, that HRV never leaves the maker’s own app.
What is a screenless fitness band, and how big is the market?
A wrist tracker with no display. It records heart rate, sleep and movement around the clock, and everything is read in a phone app. WHOOP created the category.
It is now one of the fastest-moving parts of the wearable market. Omdia estimates screenless trackers made up more than 15% of basic band shipments in the second quarter of 2026 [5]. Garmin told investors that demand for its Cirqa band beat expectations, which we covered in the third-quarter wearable results.
Which screenless bands can you buy, and what do they cost?
| Band | Launched | Price | Subscription | Battery |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WHOOP 5.0 and MG | May 2025 | Included in the membership | Required: $199, $239 or $359 a year [1] | 14 days [6] |
| Google Fitbit Air | May 2026 | $99.99 [2] | Optional: Google Health Premium, $9.99 a month [2] | 7 days [2] |
| Garmin Cirqa | July 2026 | $199.99 [6] | Optional: Connect+, $69.99 a year [6] | 10 days [6] |
| Polar Loop | September 2025 | $199.99 [6][7] | None | 8 days [7] |
| Amazfit Helio Strap | June 2025 | $99.99 [3] | None | 10 days [3] |
| Noom Band | Early 2027 | Not sold at retail | Bundled into employer and health plan programmes [4] | Not stated |
Over three years the gap is about ten to one. The sensor does not explain it. In one reviewer’s side-by-side workouts, the Cirqa’s heart rate stayed within about a beat of WHOOP and the Fitbit Air [6]. That is one tester, not a validation study, but nobody is claiming the $100 bands read a different heart.
What does a membership buy that a $100 band does not?
Interpretation and services. WHOOP’s top tier adds an ECG and blood pressure insights on its MG band [1], and the company now sells blood tests and access to clinicians, which we covered in Oura’s purchase of Counsel Health. Google keeps its AI coach in Google Health Premium [2]. Garmin charges for Connect+.
Polar and Amazfit charge nothing after the purchase. That is the same split we found in our map of health subscription prices: the hardware is getting cheap, and companies charge for what they tell you about the data.
How does data from each band reach an app?
By three routes. On iPhone, the band’s app can write to Apple Health. On Android, it can write to Health Connect. And some makers run a cloud API that a developer connects to directly.
- WHOOP sends sleep, heart rate, resting heart rate, respiratory rate, blood oxygen, workouts and steps to Apple Health. Its own table lists HRV among the things it does not send, and Recovery and Strain scores are not sent either [8]. Those come through the WHOOP API, where a new app can serve only 10 members until WHOOP approves it [9].
- Polar Loop sends sleep times, steps and workout heart rate to Apple Health. Polar’s page is blunt: “Continuous heart rate is not synced” [10]. Health Connect gets sleep stages and blood oxygen as well, and no HRV [11]. Polar’s AccessLink API carries continuous heart rate and its overnight recovery measure [12].
- Garmin Cirqa syncs through Garmin Connect, like a Garmin watch. The basics reach the phone. HRV status and Body Battery do not, as we set out in what Garmin syncs to Apple Health and Health Connect. Garmin’s API reopened in October with a free tier and fees at scale.
- Google Fitbit Air is the most open on Android. Google’s list of what it writes to Health Connect includes HRV [13]. On iPhone, Google Health has written exercise, sleep, steps and vitals to Apple Health since August, as we covered in the Fitbit API migration. The cloud route is the Google Health API, which requires a security review.
- Amazfit Helio Strap sends heart rate, blood oxygen and sleep to Apple Health, and has sent HRV since a firmware update in October 2025 [14]. We found no public cloud API for it.
- Noom Band has announced nothing about sharing data. Noom’s chief executive said it built its own device so that no partner’s app would compete with Noom’s to interpret the signal [4]. Do not assume it will sync anywhere else.
What should product teams do about screenless bands?
- Read the phone’s health store first, and expect the basics. Sleep, steps, workouts and some heart rate arrive from every band on sale. Plan features around those.
- If a feature needs HRV or a recovery score, budget for cloud APIs. That means one integration per brand, each with its own gate: WHOOP’s approval, Garmin’s fees, Google’s security review.
- If you are choosing a band for a programme, check the data path before the price. A $99.99 band that writes HRV to Apple Health may serve you better than a $359 one whose HRV needs an API integration. Test it on a real phone before you order in bulk.
- Keep a version that works with no band at all. Most people in any programme will not wear one. Phone data covers steps and sleep timing for everyone else.
The band itself is now a $100 product, or a free one. What you can build on it depends less on the sensor than on where the maker lets the data go.
References
- WHOOP Unveils WHOOP 5.0 and WHOOP MG. BusinessWire, 8 May 2025. WHOOP One $199, Peak $239, Life $359 a year. https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20250508546933/en/WHOOP-Unveils-WHOOP-5.0-and-WHOOP-MG-Powerful-New-Devices-with-Breakthrough-Health-an
- Droid Life. (2026). Fitbit Air release date and price are official. 7 May 2026. https://www.droid-life.com/2026/05/07/fitbit-air-release-date-price-official/
- Zepp Health. (2025). Amazfit introduces Balance 2 smartwatch and Helio Strap. Press release, 24 June 2025. https://www.zepp.com/press-release/amazfit-introduces-balance-2-smartwatch-and-helio-strap-for-smarter-training-better-recovery-and-peak-performance
- Landi, H. (2026). HLTH 2026: Noom pushes deeper into connected health with new wearable, Noom Band. Fierce Healthcare, 16 November 2026. https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/health-tech/hlth26-noom-expands-metabolic-health-strategy-new-wearable-noom-band
- TelecomLead. (2026). Global wearable band shipments fall 2% as Garmin gains and AI health devices expand, citing Omdia. 13 August 2026. https://telecomlead.com/smart-phone/global-wearable-band-shipments-fall-2-as-garmin-gains-and-ai-health-devices-expand-127289
- the5krunner. (2026). Garmin CIRQA vs WHOOP, LOOP, Fitbit Air and Helio Strap. 6 August 2026. https://the5krunner.com/2026/08/06/cirqa-vs-whoop-comparison/
- Android Central. (2025). The 8-day Polar Loop tracker challenges Whoop and Garmin with subscription-free workout data. 3 September 2025. https://www.androidcentral.com/wearables/polar/polar-loop-challenges-whoop-and-garmin-with-subscription-free-workout-data
- WHOOP. WHOOP data export and new app integrations for members. Updated 16 November 2026. https://www.whoop.com/us/en/thelocker/access-your-whoop-data-with-new-integrations-data-export-options/
- WHOOP. App Approval: development limited to 10 members; public launch requires approval. https://developer.whoop.com/docs/developing/app-approval/
- Polar. Connecting Polar Flow with Apple Health. Retrieved 18 November 2026. https://support.polar.com/en/support/connecting_polar_flow_with_apple_health
- Polar. Connecting Polar Flow app to Health Connect. Retrieved 18 November 2026. https://support.polar.com/en/flow-app-health-connect
- Polar. AccessLink API documentation. Retrieved 18 November 2026. https://www.polar.com/accesslink-api/
- Google Health Help Center. Sync Google Health with Health Connect, including the data types Google Health can write. https://support.google.com/fitbit/answer/14506680
- Gadgets & Wearables. (2025). Helio Strap gains HRV sync with Apple Health. 28 October 2025. https://gadgetsandwearables.com/2025/10/28/helio-strap-hrv-sync-apple-health/
- Sahha. Integrations. https://sahha.ai/integrations/